The Deregulation of Downzoning
Senate Bill 382: A Shift in Municipal Zoning Practices
The passage of Senate Bill 382, also known as the Disaster Recovery Act of 2024, has included significant changes to zoning practices for municipalities within North Carolina. By significantly restricting local governments' ability to implement down-zoning measures, the law represents a major shift in how zoning decisions are made, with substantial implications for urban planning, development, and community growth. Subsequently, ensuring property owners that zoning changes could not reduce property rights or development potential without the consent from the property owner.
Key Provisions of Senate Bill 382
Definition of Down-Zoning
The bill provides a broad definition of down-zoning, encompassing any zoning ordinance that:
Decreases the development density to levels less than previously allowed.
Reduces the permitted uses specified in a zoning ordinance or land development regulation.
Creates nonconformities on land outside residential zoning districts, including nonconforming uses, lots, structures, improvements, or site elements.
Requirement for Unanimous Consent
Under the new law, local governments are prohibited from initiating, enacting, or enforcing any down-zoning measures without unanimous written consent from all affected property owners. This requirement places a significant constraint on municipalities, making it exceedingly difficult to implement unilateral mass zoning changes.
Retroactive Application
Senate Bill 382 applies retroactively to any down-zoning decisions made within 180 days prior to its passage. As a result, zoning changes enacted since June 14, 2024, could be rendered illegal, creating potential legal and administrative challenges for local governments.
Impacts on Development and Land Use
The legislation's restrictions on down-zoning will have impact for development and land use planning, including:
Higher-Density Development: Municipalities lose the ability to curb and stop higher density development. This could decrease city’s ability to placate NIMBY reactions to proposed development.
Floodplain Management: Local governments may face challenges in limiting development in flood-prone areas, which could have longer impacts.
Zoning Transitions: Rezoning efforts aimed at encouraging specific types of development, such as commercial projects, may now qualify as down-zoning if they reduce previously permitted uses.
Specific Examples of Impact
Transit-Oriented Development: Cities aiming to reduce auto-dependent uses over time in transit opportunity areas may struggle to implement such plans, as phasing out certain uses could be classified as down-zoning, if it regulates against the property’s current use.
Development Standards: Changes to setbacks, buffers, or open space requirements may be restricted if they decrease development density.
Short-Term Rentals: Efforts to regulate short-term rentals by reducing permitted uses could be impeded by the law.
Flood Mitigation: Adopting local ordinances to meet federal and state flood mitigation standards may conflict with down-zoning restrictions.
Prohibits Reducing Residential Development: Rezoning a corridor from multifamily to single-family zoning will now require unanimous consent from property owners, effectively limiting municipalities' ability to outlaw multifamily.
The Disaster Recovery Act of 2024 fundamentally alters the landscape of municipal zoning by curbing local governments' ability to reduce density, limit uses or create nonconformities. While intended to provide property owners with greater protection, the law imposes substantial challenges on municipalities seeking to manage growth, address infrastructure concerns, and meet state and federal mandates. As local governments grapple with these changes, the full implications of the will continue to unfold, reshaping the future of urban planning and development in the state.
CLT Public Relations hosts a quarterly The Land Use Coffee - this meeting is specifically for architects, developers, builders, and those who are interested in in-depth conversations on building codes, UDO, and other regulatory issues. Our next meeting will be focused on regulatory changes that went into effect in 2025, and regulatory legislation expected in 2026.
Click here receive more information